Motorcycle Settlement 2024

Rear-End Collision and Underinsured Motorist Claim $100,000 Total Recovery in Lake County, Illinois 

$100,000.00

Key Takeaways

  • USAA insured both our client and the at-fault driver, requiring separate evaluations under two different coverages.
  • USAA paid the at-fault driver's $50,000.00 bodily-injury liability limit.
  • We then pursued an underinsured motorist claim through our client's own policy and obtained an additional $50,000.00.
  • The two claims produced a combined $100,000.00 recovery without filing a lawsuit.

What Happened

Our client was exiting the expressway toward Route 137/Buckley Street in Lake County during the early morning hours. She stopped in the right-turn lane for a red light while the surrounding traffic remained stationary.

The driver immediately behind her failed to stop and struck the rear of her vehicle. The impact propelled our client forward and caused her head to make repeated contact with the headrest.

The Injury

Our client experienced pain and stiffness in her neck, lower back, and right shoulder. She went to an emergency room for evaluation and later received additional hospital care.

She continued experiencing stiffness and aching that affected her daily activities. Her treatment included physical therapy and chiropractic care over approximately nine months. Her documented medical expenses totaled $47,110.46.

The Insurance Company's First Offer

USAA accepted the $50,000.00 demand presented under the at-fault driver’s bodily-injury liability coverage. That payment represented the available liability limit for the at-fault driver.

USAA did not make an immediate offer under our client’s underinsured motorist coverage and requested additional information before evaluating that separate claim.

Why That Offer Was Too Low

The $50,000.00 liability payment was only $2,889.54 more than our client’s documented medical expenses. It did not adequately account for approximately nine months of treatment, the pain and stiffness she experienced, or the effect of the injuries on her normal activities.

Because the at-fault driver’s available liability coverage was insufficient to fully address those losses, we pursued additional compensation through our client’s underinsured motorist coverage.

Damages Breakdown

Final Settlement$100,000.00

What We Did

Our firm investigated the collision despite the absence of a police report. We collected and reviewed the medical records and bills, documented the treatment course, opened the applicable insurance claims, and submitted a demand to USAA.

After obtaining the at-fault driver’s $50,000.00 liability limit, we pursued a separate underinsured motorist claim through our client’s policy. We provided the additional information requested by USAA and negotiated an additional $50,000.00 UIM payment. We also addressed the outstanding medical liens and bills as part of completing the matter.

Timeline

  1. Accident occurred December 6, 2022
  2. Key treatment began December 13, 2022
  3. Treatment completed / maximum medical improvement reached August 1, 2023
  4. Demand sent November 2, 2023
  5. Settlement agreement reached January 16, 2024

Total duration: 13 months

Why This Case Matters

A payment of the at-fault driver’s liability limit does not always fully compensate an injured person. When the available liability coverage is insufficient, underinsured motorist coverage may provide an additional source of recovery through the injured person’s own policy.

Here, USAA insured both drivers, but the bodily-injury liability claim and the UIM claim still required separate evaluations. After obtaining the at-fault driver’s $50,000.00 liability limit, we continued presenting the medical evidence and the effect of the injuries under our client’s UIM coverage.

That process produced a second $50,000.00 payment and increased the total recovery to $100,000.00 without a lawsuit.

The Final Result

$100,000.00

The claims resolved for a combined $100,000.00. USAA first paid the at-fault driver’s $50,000.00 bodily-injury liability limit. We then obtained an additional $50,000.00 through our client’s underinsured motorist coverage. Both claims were completed approximately 13 months after the collision without depositions, court appearances, or a lawsuit.

Frequently Asked Questions

An underinsured motorist claim may provide additional compensation when the at-fault driver’s liability coverage is not sufficient to address the injuries and damages caused by a collision. The claim is submitted through the injured person’s own policy, but the claimant must still establish liability, causation, and damages. In this case, the UIM claim produced an additional $50,000.00 after the at-fault driver’s $50,000.00 liability limit was paid.

About the Attorney

Nicholas S. Dollenmaier

Nicholas S. Dollenmaier

Partner | Illinois Personal Injury Attorney

View full bio →

Get a Free Consultation

Talk to a lawyer about your case

If you or a loved one was hurt in an accident anywhere in Illinois, don't wait. The sooner we get involved, the stronger your case. Call us for a free consultation — we'll listen to what happened, give you an honest assessment of your options, and tell you exactly what comes next.

No runaround. No fees unless we win.