$35,000 Collapsed Chair Injury Settlement in Crest Hill
Key Takeaways
- Our client was hurt when a chair collapsed beneath her at a social club, tearing her right rotator cuff.
- The club's insurer made no offer — it only asked for more paperwork.
- We filed suit in Will County and used requests to admit to lock in the authenticity of her medical bills.
- We settled for $35,000.00 and reduced her medical liens to maximize her net recovery.
What Happened
Our client was sitting on a chair at a social club in Crest Hill, Illinois when the chair collapsed beneath her, catching her leg and causing her to fall onto her right side.
The Injury
Our client was diagnosed with partial-thickness tears of her right rotator cuff (the supraspinatus and infraspinatus tendons) and biceps tendon, along with right hip and right ankle pain and swelling. She treated conservatively over roughly five months — a same-day emergency room visit (she was not admitted), chiropractic care, a right-shoulder MRI, orthopedic follow-up, and 18 physical therapy visits. She did not have surgery. Her medical bills totaled $22,672.00.
The Insurance Company's First Offer
The club’s liability insurer did not make an offer. Its first substantive response was a letter requesting additional documentation — client information, medical records and bills, and liability details — in order to evaluate the claim, rather than any monetary offer.
Why That Offer Was Too Low
With the insurer declining to make an offer and continuing to dispute liability and causation, there was no fair resolution available without litigation. We filed suit to move the claim forward and build the record needed to value it.
Damages Breakdown
| Final Settlement | $35,000.00 |
|---|
What We Did
We filed suit in Will County, served the defendant, and took the case through written discovery and our client’s deposition. We served requests to admit that locked in the authenticity and reasonableness of her $22,672.00 in medical bills while the defense continued to dispute liability and causation. That pressure led to a negotiated $35,000.00 settlement, and we reduced her outstanding provider liens under the Illinois Health Care Services Lien Act to maximize her net recovery.
Timeline
- INCIDENT OCCURRED December 5, 2024
- EMERGENCY TREATMENT December 5, 2024
- PHYSICAL THERAPY COMPLETED October 22, 2024
- LAWSUIT FILED August 27, 2025
- DEFENDANT SERVED October 26, 2025
- PLAINTIFF DEPOSITION June 3, 2026
- SETTLEMENT REACHED September 14, 2026
Total duration: Approximately 28 months
Why This Case Matters
An insurer’s refusal to make an offer — or a demand for endless documentation — is not the end of a claim. Filing suit and using discovery tools such as requests to admit can establish the validity of the medical treatment and move a stalled claim to a fair resolution.
The Final Result
$35,000.00
We obtained a $35,000.00 settlement for our client after the club’s insurer declined to make an offer and disputed liability and causation. The case required filing suit in Will County, taking the client’s deposition, and using requests to admit to establish her medical bills, after which we negotiated the settlement and reduced her provider liens to maximize her net recovery.
Frequently Asked Questions
It is an Illinois law that limits how much medical providers can collectively claim out of a personal-injury recovery, which helps protect the injured person’s share of a settlement. We used it here to reduce the client’s provider liens.
It means the insurer argues the injuries were not actually caused by the incident. Medical records, imaging, and a client’s testimony are used to show that the treatment was related to the fall.
About the Attorney
Get a Free Consultation
Talk to a lawyer about your case
If you or a loved one was hurt in an accident anywhere in Illinois, don't wait. The sooner we get involved, the stronger your case. Call us for a free consultation — we'll listen to what happened, give you an honest assessment of your options, and tell you exactly what comes next.
No runaround. No fees unless we win.