Slip & Fall Settlement 2016

$237,500.00 Hotel Slip-and-Fall Settlement in Matteson

$237,500.00

Key Takeaways

  • Our client shattered her ankle slipping on snow and ice while leaving a hotel, requiring emergency surgery.
  • The hotel denied liability under Illinois's natural-accumulation rule and first offered just $30,000.00.
  • After we moved to sanction the defense for discovery violations, the case settled at a court-ordered settlement conference.
  • The $237,500.00 settlement was nearly eight times the pre-conference offer, against $110,056.15 in medical bills.

What Happened

On January 12, 2025, our client slipped on snow and ice on the walkway while exiting a hotel in Matteson, Illinois and fell, severely injuring her right ankle.

The Injury

Our client suffered a trimalleolar fracture of the right ankle — a break involving three parts of the ankle with a ligament (syndesmotic) injury. She was admitted to the emergency room and underwent open reduction and internal fixation surgery the next day, with a plate and screws placed to repair the fracture. She completed four orthopedic follow-up visits and roughly 25 physical therapy sessions over about five and a half months and made a good recovery with occasional residual symptoms. Her medical bills totaled $110,056.15.

The Insurance Company's First Offer

The hotel’s insurer first denied the bodily-injury claim outright, offering only its small medical-payments coverage. Ahead of the court-ordered settlement conference, the defense made a monetary offer of just $30,000.00 against our $1,000,000 policy-limits demand.

Why That Offer Was Too Low

A $30,000.00 offer did not come close to the value of a surgical ankle fracture. Our client had undergone emergency surgery with hardware implanted, incurred $110,056.15 in medical bills, and faced a lasting injury. The offer ignored the severity of the fracture, the surgery, and the documented damages.

Damages Breakdown

Final Settlement $237,500.00

What We Did

We filed suit in Cook County and amended the complaint to name the correct corporate owner of the hotel. We pursued written discovery and our client’s deposition, and when the defense failed to meet its discovery obligations, we moved to sanction it — seeking to bar its evidence and strike its defenses. That pressure, carried into a court-ordered settlement conference, overcame the hotel’s liability denial and its low offer. The case settled for $237,500.00, nearly eight times the pre-conference offer, and we negotiated the client’s health-insurance lien to improve her net recovery.

Timeline

  1. ACCIDENT OCCURRED January 12, 2025
  2. EMERGENCY TREATMENT AND HOSPITAL ADMISSION January 12, 2025
  3. ANKLE SURGERY (ORIF) January 13, 2025
  4. PHYSICAL THERAPY COMPLETED June 30, 2025
  5. LAWSUIT FILED January 21, 2026
  6. DEFENDANT SERVED February 4, 2026
  7. MOTION TO SANCTION DEFENDANT FILED June 5, 2026
  8. PLAINTIFF DEPOSITION July 17, 2026
  9. SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE October 9, 2026
  10. SETTLEMENT REACHED October 20, 2026

Total duration: approximately 21 months

Why This Case Matters

A liability denial and a low first offer are not the ceiling on a case. Developing the medical record and holding the defense to its discovery obligations — including moving for sanctions when it fails to comply — can transform a case’s value, here from a $30,000.00 offer to a $237,500.00 settlement.

The Final Result

$237,500.00

We obtained a $237,500.00 settlement for our client approximately 21 months after a fall that shattered her ankle and required surgery. The hotel denied liability under Illinois’s natural-accumulation snow-and-ice doctrine and offered only $30,000.00; by filing suit, developing the record, and moving to sanction the defense for discovery violations, we drove the value up nearly eightfold and resolved the case at a court-ordered settlement conference.

Frequently Asked Questions

Under Illinois law, a property owner generally is not liable for a fall caused by a natural accumulation of snow or ice. An injured person often must show an unnatural or man-made accumulation, which is why these cases are vigorously defended and require careful development of the facts. 

The court can impose sanctions — including barring the defendant’s evidence or striking its defenses. Moving for sanctions can both protect the case and increase pressure on the defense to resolve it fairly. 

About the Attorney

Komal Tailor

Komal Tailor

Associate Attorney

View full bio →

Get a Free Consultation

Talk to a lawyer about your case

If you or a loved one was hurt in an accident anywhere in Illinois, don't wait. The sooner we get involved, the stronger your case. Call us for a free consultation — we'll listen to what happened, give you an honest assessment of your options, and tell you exactly what comes next.

No runaround. No fees unless we win.